.It's deja vu throughout again for the Bulldogs, lambasted straight out of the finals with Luke Beveridge's doubtful transfer the spotlight.Plus Geelong's reconstruct on the run, where the Heeney Robbery rates everlasting, Brisbane's crystal clear flaw and the much-needed significant award change.The large concerns from week among the 2024 AFL finals evaluated in Speaking Points!Watch the very best coverage of the 2024 AFL finals, with professional analysis and every game up until the Grand Final cope with no ad-breaks during play, on Kayo. New to Kayo? Start your free of cost trial today > Finals Week 1IMAGINE WHAT YOU CAN BE BUYING AS AN ALTERNATIVE. Free of charge and private help phone call 1800u00a0858u00a0858 or visit gamblinghelponline.org.au.The Full week 1 finals AFL Talking Points are in.Source: FOX SPORTSOOPS, BEVO DID IT AGAINNext year, the Western Bulldogs must simply attack simulate, and also miss every thing until the ultimate cycle. Due to the fact that they only always keep performing the very same things again and again.For the third year in a row their finals fate dropped to the final time for the 5th time due to the fact that the 2016 banner, they found on their own in an eradication final.And the feast-or-famine attributes of their Septembers carried on as, for the fourth time, they were knocked senseless of the finals without a win.But the deja vu does not cease there certainly because once more the Bulldogs' period ends with Luke Beveridge's decision-making arriving under fire.They were actually affordable early versus Hawthorn but points promptly collapsed on Friday evening as well as you must ponder how much of the reduction came on Thursday night, when the picked staff was actually revealed. Given that the tinkerer went to it again.Mitchell handles Ginni's bar tricks|01:44 The positional concerns started in defence, as they usually have for the Bulldogs recently. Rory Lobb's surge right into an amazingly really good trick protector carried on however he simply really did not possess adequate help Liam Jones limited Jack Gunston but failed to do much in other places, while James O'Donnell was actually effectively trumped through Calsher Dear.The 2 are actually in a similar way unskilled thus by itself that's certainly not an extensive shock yet it is actually still fairly absurd that the 56th pick in the absolute most current nationwide receipt was able to dominate the Pet dogs aerially like he did.But it wasn't only the defence, due to the fact that any sort of back 6 would certainly've struggled when must stand up for 59 inside 50s - the greater issue was actually the Canines generating simply 39 inside 50s of their own.Harvey Gallagher spent plenty of opportunity on an airfoil, as opposed to Lachie McNeil who moved forward, and also neither man possessed an impact while Lachie Bramble summarized among the Bulldogs' huge listing concerns - along with the earlier delisted Hawk required as being one of their primary representatives off halfback.Bramble simply isn't very powerful enough in that role the lack of prime Caleb Daniel, that has actually diminished sufficient defensively that he can not be soft-pedaled back, has been notable.Throw in the baffling non-selection of Rhylee West, who would certainly possess likely made an effort to limit James Sicily in the Dogs' onward fifty, along with James Harmes favored but carrying out little bit of - and also the bits-and-pieces players only seemed to be to become in the wrong places.High piloting Hawks knock senseless Bulldogs|02:26 And afterwards there is actually the Bont.Beveridge fired up in his post-match press conference when the additions of perhaps the AFL's best player were actually questioned." Have you received realities on that (his pause the ground)? He may have got stuck on (the seat) for a minute or 2 longer (than considered), however he was actually okay," the coach said." He made an effort to raise our team in the final one-fourth, he kicked an objective, he virtually booted a second (a shot touched through ally Aaron Naughton near free throw line), which was actually the information at three-quarter opportunity." Whether he was actually holding an injury or not, Marcus Bontempelli had no place near sufficient influence for the Bulldogs to possess a discover Friday night, and the genuine question is actually why he wasn't in the midfield through the middle of the game - specifically if he was actually fit.Despite Beveridge's demonstrations, Bontempelli invested 22% of the second and also 3rd one-fourths mixed off the ground, and also while on the ground possessed just four fingertips, no clearances as well as no score participations, devoting virtually the whole entire period up forward.Once Bontempelli went into the center very early in the fourth one-fourth, he resembled themself once more. However it was inadequate, far too late." Absolutely no effect in a vicious final. The most effective player, the All-Australian captain, is either on the bench or even onward," as Kane Cornes put it on 9's Sunday Footy Show.None of these positional phone calls, on their own, are actually why the Bulldogs lost. The Hawks also participated in truly damn properly, with their stress leading to the Dogs' transition activity to drop apart.But they all lead to a continual trend of Beveridge tinkering his way to each effectiveness as well as failing. He does not possess the most effective list in the AFL, like some analysts mention, since the workers down back as well as perhaps in parts of the midfield stay an issue.Dejected Bevo particulars what went wrong|09:39 Yet their absolute best is clearly adequate. As always accompanies the Pet dogs, they participated in brilliant footy at times throughout the home and away season yet were not steady enough to gain the double odds. (They have still never finished in the best four under Beveridge.) So when they ran into a red-hot Hawthorn, one bad night sufficed to end their season. It is actually a little bit of an embarassment, due to the fact that this staff was actually definitely sufficient over the rear one-half of the year to gain multiple finals (and also perhaps even the large one), however they dropped short in their one possibility - so they can only point the finger at themselves.They are actually as well excellent, and also Beveridge has actually been actually as well prosperous over his assignment, to push a modification on top. But they are almost caught in this particular loophole of good-but-not-good-enough, and if it's hugely aggravating for onlookers, it has to be actually even worse for the Bulldogs faithful.WHAT'S NEW PUSSYCATS?Geelong's capability to continue to be on top of the AFL mountain range for as long is actually entirely remarkable.When you consider the absolute most effective staffs in recent opportunities, Geelong's tale is actually much more impressive.Hawthorn unquestionably possessed a golden era in the early 2010s, but triumph over the Bulldogs on Friday night was their very first finals succeed in nine years.Richmond gained three banners in 4 times but now appeared destined to stay in the funk of the AFL step ladder for a variety of years along with a mass player exodus looming.On the additional palm, Geelong has lost out on September activity merely twice previously 18 times. That is awesome consistency in a competition that is actually actually developed to try as well as try in the direction of equality.One of the major variables responsible for their incredible success in the past two decades is their capacity to discover a diamond in the rough when it involves the draft.Scott opens on variety gamble|09:03 Geelong have gathered up pair of outright stars from the draft in the last few years, in Lawson Humphries and also Shaun Mannagh.Externally during in 2013's business duration, questions were actually asked about why the Cats were actually being actually so steadfast in requesting for an overdue choice back in gain in the Esava Ratugolea trade. Why were they being so firm about obtaining an additional pick back that they could not even use happened draft night?The Cats chosen Humphries, a fairly unfamiliar Swan Areas product, with the 2nd final choice of last year's draught-- select 63. Humphries has actually starred in his handful of games on top level, showcasing brilliant calmness as well as round make use of all over the half-back line.The 182cm young person is a wonderful decision-maker and also has become one of Chris Scott's 'best people' visiting of defence. On Thursday night he was one of Geelong's ideal, acquiring 20 fingertips and 486 metres gained.Then there's Shaun Mannagh, the mature-aged VFL celebrity who has become a nail down the most effective 23 in the 2nd one-half of the year. Mannagh put his label up in lightings in the 2023 VFL grand ultimate, where he booted six majors and also racked up 28 disposals. The 27-year-old was compensated along with an AFL agreement in in 2013's draught, taken along with pick 36, as well as hasn't he paid off the faith?Mannagh was among his side's ideal against the Energy in the qualifying final, taping 23 disposals as well as 3.1. The former Werribee item ranks best for fingertips and also addresses this season and has actually balanced 1.3 targets every activity as a medium-forward. Increasing Star Ollie Dempsey has actually also begun in jumps as well as bounds this season to become one of the best necessary gamers to an edge ready to start one more preparatory final.Not just have actually the Cats had the capacity to locate results at the draught, however their one-of-a-kind recruitment tactic has actually also observed them end up being a destination club for opposition players too.The Felines offered the ranch for ex-Giant Jeremy Cameron as well as the way of life additionally attracted right now captain Patrick Dangerfield. Add in the likes of Port Bowes, Tanner Bruhn, Tyson Stengle and also Oliver Holly, the Pet cats have actually had easy marketing on their own as a home for location players.But it's certainly not as though the Cats have not altered. 9 gamers who featured in Thursday night's certifying final victory did certainly not play in the 2022 premiership, only 2 years ago.ABC's Kyle Pollard pointed out on X that that is actually certainly not different to Richmond now." For situation, Richmond's final round crew this year possessed 11 that really did not play in their premierships," he claimed." That is actually not a knock on the Tigers, it's simply an awesome 24 months of rejuvenation from Geelong." While Chris Scott as well as the on-field celebrities acquire a lot of honors as well as appropriately therefore, the work of Stephen Wells, Andrew Mackie as well as the recruiting team is actually incomparable in this competition.Geelong control inadequate Slot Adelaide|03:02 HEENEY SIGNS UP WITH THE SCG'S IMPRESSIVE MOUNT RUSHMOREIt may not be the home of footy, however the SCG is the home of all-time finals moments.Sydney's Isaac Heeney-led comeback on Saturday mid-day joins the pantheon of unbelievable September action to have occurred at the famous venue.Former Footscray and also Sydney player turned writer Neil Cordy quipped it would be actually called 'Heeney's Break-in' after the super star's 30-disposal, three-goal game.But the fourth finals edition of the Sydney Derby might certainly not have actually also been the very best comeback by the Swans in an SCG final.Swans COMEBACK coming from 27-point deficit|03:29 Besides the 2005 banner wouldn't have been feasible if Nick Davis had not had an other-worldly 4th one-fourth in the semi-final, booting four of Sydney's 7 objectives on the evening in the space of 21 mins to stun Geelong.Don' t neglect the 1996 initial last, when any kind of rating would create for Tony Lockett, and Plugger's factor placed the Swans right into the banner decider.And hell, Sunday's training final could certainly not have actually been actually the most ideal last at the SCG this decade! Don't forget Collingwood's near-comeback in the 2022 prelim, when the Swans led by 6 targets early in the third quarter, as well as by 21 factors along with 22 mins entered the fourth?The stakes were higher in all 4 activities yet the attribute of Sydney's comeback on Sunday, versus their arch-rivals and along with some absurd personal attempts, could create it No. 1. And the very best component? It suggests we are actually getting an additional activity at the SCG in two full weeks' opportunity, when the Swans lot either Slot Adelaide or Hawthorn in a prelim.Swans-Port is actually exciting after the method the Electrical power dismantled them a few weeks back Swans-Hawks is actually even a lot better, provided exactly how much Sam Mitchell's guys have come because being belted by John Longmire's edge to fall to 1-6 on the season.Let's merely hope it's one more near one." ULTIMATE RIDE" Heeney Wall mount ceases SCG|00:30' WORRYING SIGNS' COUGARS REQUIRED TO ADDRESSBrisbane might have placed Carlton to the falchion along with an initial fifty percent leveling on Saturday evening, yet Fox Footy's professionals dread there's still problems for coach Chris Fagan.Despite a stunning start where the Lions jumped bent on a 60-0 lead, resigning Carlton to a 50-year footy reduced, Brisbane after that went greater than thirty minutes without a goal.And they handled to butcher an amount of possibilities when the warm stemmed from a rising Woe ensemble." Brisbane, I reckon there's some distressing signs certainly there for Chris Fagan," three-time premiership Tiger Jack Riewoldt claimed." They must possess done a number on Carlton tonight. They should have put that nail in the coffin early in the second fifty percent." Regrettably, they allow all of them back in. They really did not win sturdy." The video game ended following part time." AFL fantastic Garry Lyon conceded, highlighting the reality they succeeded by just 28 aspects - regardless of the early 60-0 scoreline.From that factor in the second condition, Brisbane were outscored 71-39. Cougars BLITZ Woe in Eradication Final|02:39" 2nd one-half has actually been actually a problem by means of the training course of the year. A small amount of failure," Lyon said.Lions great Jonathan Brown stated he worries the concern is mental for the young Lions, as miscalculation as well as an inability to maintain their initial half pressure continues to reach." I really feel as if it is actually not a fitness thing, certainly not an energy point. I assume it is actually a little bit of a mental turn off," he mentioned." It resides in their scalp." They booted properly very early in the activity (versus Carlton), but after half opportunity they were usual." I assume when opposition acquires an operate on, there's a sense of panic. Some anxiety in there. There's some scars, no questions about that." They have not managed to deal with the tension in those essential moments with those key boots-- that is actually visiting be actually the challenge following week." They miss a great deal of effortless shots." I have actually enjoyed all of them closely all year-- I'm an enthusiastic Brisbane Lions follower. They miss out on easy shots at target. Set shots or on the run." Versus cry, Logan Morris reached the article from straight in front while the edge butchered an additional opportunity when they had an overlap inside 50 and also stopped working to hit a target.Riewoldt described the precision concerns because of "reverse stress". They place 15th in the AFL for precision this year, ahead of simply West Coast, Richmond as well as Slot Adelaide.In their final 4 suits, Brisbane have gone 44.64 on the scoreboard, with goalkicking costing them a top-four place when they shed 8.16 to GWS' 13.4 in Around 22. They likewise lost winnable games versus Carlton in Opening Sphere (12.13 to 13.8), Collingwood in Round 3 (10.12 to 14.8) as well as Geelong in Around 6 (4.13 to 9.9) as a result of their mistake." What possess our experts came to drop?"|04:23' WE'VE GOT TO ADJUSTMENT THAT RULE': IS ACTUALLY AFL HONOR telephone call UNFAIR?Players as well as experts state it's opportunity for the AFL to listen to the supporters as well as modify the qualifications standards surrounding the Score and also Objective of the Year awards.First it was Jeremy Cameron's enchanting end, put near to the limit product line on Thursday evening, as he got the Pussy-cats off to an aspiration start at the Adelaide Oval. On Sunday night it was actually Swans celebrity Isaac Heeney, that levitated to take among the all-time excellent grabs. The most awful component-- neither are going to be actually qualified for the distinguished awards.As it stands, simply instants in the home and away time are taken into consideration for the honors, which exist on Brownlow Medal night just before the marvelous last. However back seeing 2 of the time's very most captivating instants, there is actually been actually plenty of ask for the AFL to alter its rules. "Our experts've come to transform that regulation, Jeremy Cameron stopped target of the year in finals and then Isaac Heeney's taken score of the year," Swans tiny ahead Tom Papley informed 3AW post-match. Jezza opens up finals set with STUNNER!|00:35 Network 9's Damian Barrett additionally signed up with the chorus of professionals calling for adjustment, mentioning he strongly believed Heeney's hanger was the very best score of the year. "That to me is actually score of the year yet sadly it won't be actually consisted of in the considerations," he lamented on the Sunday Footy Show.Former Tiger and Bulldog Nathan Brown was in agreeance." I assume it ought to be actually, you go back to 1997, Aussie Jones stopped the objective of the year in the splendid last, individuals state the various other staffs don't obtain a possibility, I imply there is actually a number of chances," he said.Jones stopped an exceptional running objective in the '97 splendid final, while past Roo Aaron Edwards took a substantial score against Hawthorn in the 2007 semi-final that has actually been "shed in past" provided its own ineligibility for the award.Former AFL player Josh Jenkins was actually likewise amongst those who spoke up regarding their disdain, taking to X to claim: "Target of the year straight certainly there ... wait they've finalized nominations." As a football frat, players who stand up on the greatest phase of all are actually commended and also locate their place in footy mythology, therefore why are the Mark of the Year as well as Objective of the Year honors uninformed of that?When you consider the most ideal players to play the game, those that have actually tasted success in September are consistently amongst the initial gamers that come to mind.Think Michael Voss, Luke Hodge and also Joel Selwood. Premiership captains who are actually held in the highest possible mind through all. Gamers are determined through their performances in finals." Leo Barry you star" was ingrained in history when the Swans gun drifted throughout the pack to take that well-known mark. Richmond captain Trent Cotchin's heritage was cemented when he took his side back to the promised land. There's no warranty that Heeney's hanger will trump Jamie Elliott's ANZAC Day unique, or that Cameron's insane finish would appropriate that of Scar Daicos or Harley davidson Reid's targets, but they must at least be actually opponents.